Roofbow 1 and 2

[DoctorJazz]

I already submitted the first photo as Roofbow a few days ago.
Here are two versions of the photo.
Which one is more interesting, if either?

[Pat]

Hi Doc. And Welcome. I'm not really seeing any colour (of a rainbow type), on the roof, if that was your aim here, as per your earlier post. You seem to be quite underexposed.
Aside from that, I think I would have stepped back and tried to get more of the building in the pic.
Also, for critique you should open a thread in the appropriate category below, in the comment and critique section. This is the "Edit my pic" domain where we edit your pic, thusly...

[DoctorJazz]

OK, I'll try to continue this in the correct category.....Sorry for the mistake!

To follow up, I'll submit my reply to Landscapes in the photo critique section.
It will include an attachment of another image with more of the building shown.

See what you think.

[StephenK]

Hi Doctor Jazz :^)

I was working on this photo anyway looking to see if it was possible to better bring-out the rainbows reflection
on the wet roof, using complex masking to tackle the task. I recently signed up with guygowan.com who specializes in
such masking when tackling his images... Approached head-on with the general use of adjustment layers the reflection
tends to get lost a little in the transition.... but with selective masking there seems to be more of it wanting to come through.... :^)

[DoctorJazz]

Thanks for the information StephenK! I'll try to learn more about your
masking suggestion.....and the website you mentioned.